欧美电力市场操纵行为监管原则分析及其对中国的启示

廖侃; 丁肇豪; 舒隽; 陈杰; 赵进

doi:10.7500/AEPS20191117002

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

欧美电力市场操纵行为监管原则分析及其对中国的启示

观点 | 更新时间：2025-06-16

- 欧美电力市场操纵行为监管原则分析及其对中国的启示
- Analysis on Regulatory Principles of Manipulative Behavior for European and American Electricity Markets and Enlightenment to China
- 电力系统自动化-方正平台 2020年44卷第14期页码：1-8
- 作者机构：
  
  1. 华北电力大学电气与电子工程学院，北京市 102206
  2. 波托马克经济咨询公司,费尔法克斯市 22030，美国
  3. 柏林洪堡大学,柏林市 10117，德国
- 作者简介：
  
  廖侃(1997—)，男，硕士研究生，主要研究方向：电力市场。E-mail：liaokan@ncepu.cn
  丁肇豪(1988—)，男，通信作者，博士，副教授，主要研究方向：电力市场和电动交通系统。E-mail：zhaohao.ding@ncepu.edu.cn
  舒隽(1974—)，男，博士，副教授，主要研究方向：电力经济与电力系统规划。E-mail：junshu2000@sohu.com
- 基金信息：
  
  中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助项目(2019MS054);北京市优秀人才培养资助项目(X19048);国家电网公司科技项目(5100-201957474A-0-0-00)
- DOI：10.7500/AEPS20191117002
  中图分类号：
- 收稿日期：2019-11-17，
  
  修回日期：2020-03-10，
  
  网络出版日期：2020-04-22，
  
  纸质出版日期：2020-07-25
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
廖侃,丁肇豪,舒隽等.欧美电力市场操纵行为监管原则分析及其对中国的启示[J].电力系统自动化,2020,44(14):1-8.

LIAO Kan,DING Zhaohao,SHU Jun,et al.Analysis on Regulatory Principles of Manipulative Behavior for European and American Electricity Markets and Enlightenment to China[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2020,44(14):1-8.
廖侃,丁肇豪,舒隽等.欧美电力市场操纵行为监管原则分析及其对中国的启示[J].电力系统自动化,2020,44(14):1-8. DOI： 10.7500/AEPS20191117002.

LIAO Kan,DING Zhaohao,SHU Jun,et al.Analysis on Regulatory Principles of Manipulative Behavior for European and American Electricity Markets and Enlightenment to China[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2020,44(14):1-8. DOI： 10.7500/AEPS20191117002.

摘要

随着中国电力现货市场建设的不断推进，市场交易体系和交易品种日趋复杂。未来各类交易品种交织关联，将导致电力市场操纵行为日益复杂和隐蔽。各类操纵行为可能会扭曲市场交易结果，影响市场对资源优化配置的有效引导，继而影响电力市场改革的有效性和可持续性，是电力市场建设发展过程中需要重视和严密监管的问题。对此，文中针对性地研究分析了欧美电力市场中存在的操纵行为，通过介绍操纵行为的定义、分类及原理，结合案例总结了电力市场操纵方法的一般规律和对应的市场监管原则。在此基础上，结合中国电力市场的发展现状，提出了针对中国电力市场监管体系的启示和建议。

Abstract

With the continuous advancement of the construction of Chinese electricity spot market

the market trading system and the types of trading have been becoming increasingly complex. In the future

various types of transactions will be associated

and this will make the manipulative behaviors of the electricity market increasingly complex and hidden. All types of manipulative behaviors may distort the results of market transactions

undermine the effective guidance of market for the optimal allocation of resources

and then

affect the effectiveness and sustainability of electricity market reforms. These are issues that need to be seriously addressed and tightly supervised during the development of the electricity market. To solve the above problems

this paper specifically analyzes the manipulative behaviors in the European and American electricity markets. By introducing the definition

classification

and principles of manipulative behaviors

this paper summarizes the general laws of manipulation methods and the corresponding market regulatory principles through case studies. Based on this

combined with the current development situation of Chinese electricity market

this paper puts forward some enlightenment and suggestions for the regulatory system of Chinese electricity market.

关键词

Keywords

references

葛睿 , 陈龙翔 , 王轶禹 , 等 . 中国电力市场建设路径优选及设计 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2017 , 41 ( 24 ): 10 - 15 .

GE Rui , CHEN Longxiang , WANG Yiyu , et al . Optimization and design of construction route for electricity market in China [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2017 , 41 ( 24 ): 10 - 15 .

RAHIMI A F , SHEFFRIN A Y . Effective market monitoring in deregulated electricity markets [J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems . 2003 , 18 ( 2 ): 486 - 493 .

KLEIT A N . What is market manipulation? Lessons from Barclays and Powhatan [J]. The Electricity Journal , 2019 , 32 ( 1 ): 1 - 5 .

HELMAN U . Market power monitoring and mitigation in the US wholesale power markets [J]. Energy , 2006 , 31 ( 6 ): 877 - 904 .

FALBO P , FATTORE M , STEFANI S . A new index for electricity spot markets [J]. Energy Policy , 2010 , 38 ( 6 ): 2739 - 2750 .

SIOSHANSI F P . Competitive electricity markets: questions remain about design, implementation, performance [J]. The Electricity Journal , 2008 , 21 ( 2 ): 74 - 87 .

夏清，黎灿兵，江健健，等 . 国外电力市场的监管方法、指标与手段 [J]. 电网技术 , 2003 ， 27 ( 3 ): 1 - 4 .

XIA Qing , LI Canbing , JIANG Jianjian , et al . Electricity market surveillance summary [J]. Power System Technology , 2003 ， 27 ( 3 ): 1 - 4 .

黄晓玲，郭国川 . 电力市场操纵力问题探析 [J]. 中国电力 , 2003 ， 36 ( 6 ): 39 - 44 .

HUANG Xiaoling , GUO Guochuan . Analysis of market power in liberalized electricity markets [J]. Electric Power , 2003 ， 36 ( 6 ): 39 - 44 .

刘敦楠，李瑞庆，陈雪青，等 . 电力市场监管指标及市场评价体系 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2004 , 28 ( 9 ): 16 - 21 .

LIU Dunnan , LI Ruiqing , CHEN Xueqing , et al . Surveillance indices and evaluating system of electricity market [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2004 , 28 ( 9 ): 16 - 21 .

林济铿，祁达才，倪以信 . 电力市场监管辅助系统之研究 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2001 , 25 ( 14 ): 7 - 10 .

LIN Jikeng , QI Dacai , NI Yixin . Study for power market surveillance system [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2001 ， 25 ( 14 ): 7 - 10 .

黎灿兵，康重庆，江健健，等 . 电力市场监管中的信息披露与市场评估 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2003 , 27 ( 21 ): 1 - 6 .

LI Canbing , KANG Chongqing , JIANG Jianjian , et al . Study on information publishing and market assessment in electricity market surveillance [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2003 , 27 ( 21 ): 1 - 6 .

薛禹胜，李天然，尹霞，等 . 广义阻塞及市场力的研究框架 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2010 , 34 ( 21 ): 1 - 10 .

XUE Yusheng , LI Tianran , YIN Xia , et al . A research framework for generalized congestions and market power [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2010 , 34 ( 21 ): 1 - 10 .

李瑞庆，刘敦楠，何光宇，等 . 电力市场运营监管信息系统 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2004 , 28 ( 14 ): 18 - 22 .

LI Ruiqing , LIU Dunnan , HE Guangyu , et al . Operating monitoring and evaluating system of electricity market [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2004 , 28 ( 14 ): 18 - 22 .

Prohibition of energy market manipulation [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/011906/M-1.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/011906/M-1.pdf .

Regulation No . 1227 / 2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2011 on wholesale energy market integrity and transparency [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-15 ]. https://eurlex.europa.eu/legalcontent/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32011R1227&from=en https://eurlex.europa.eu/legalcontent/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32011R1227&from=en .

EVANS M . Regulating electricity-market manipulation: a proposal for a new regulatory regime to proscribe all forms of manipulation [J]. Michigan Law Review , 2015 , 113 ( 4 ): 585 - 605 .

PIRRONG C . Energy market manipulation: definition, diagnosis, and deterrence [J]. Energy Law Journal , 2010 , 31 ( 1 ): 1 - 20 .

HOGAN W W . Electricity market design flaws and market manipulation [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-12 ]. https://scholar.harvard.edu/whogan/files/hogan_mdfmm_02_03_14.pdf https://scholar.harvard.edu/whogan/files/hogan_mdfmm_02_03_14.pdf .

GULER T , GROSS G . A framework for electricity market monitoring [C]// Proceedings of 15th Power Systems Computation Conference, August 22-26 , 2005 , Liege , Belgium .

LEDGERWOOD S , HARRIS D . A comparison of anti-manipulation rules in US and EU electricity and natural gas markets: a proposal for a common standard [J]. Energy Law Journal , 2012 , 33 ( 1 ): 1 - 40 .

LEDGERWOOD S D , CARPENTER P R . A framework for the analysis of market manipulation [J]. Review of Law & Economics , 2012 , 8 ( 1 ): 253 - 295 .

Staff white paper on anti-market manipulation enforcement efforts ten years after EPACT 2005[ EB/OL ]. [ 2019-11-12 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/legal/staff-reports/2016/marketmanipu lationwhitepaper.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/legal/staff-reports/2016/marketmanipulationwhitepaper.pdf .

Energy policy act of 2005[ EB/OL ]. [ 2019-11-12 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/enforce-res/EPAct2005.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/enforce-res/EPAct2005.pdf .

Deutsche Bank Energy Trading LLC : docket No . IN 12 - 4 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-12 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/enforce-res/142FERC61056.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/enforce-res/142FERC61056.pdf .

Barclays Bank PLC , Daniel Brin , Scott Connelly , Karen Levine , and Ryan Smith : docket No . IN 08 - 8 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-12 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/enforce-res/144FERC61041.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/enforce-res/144FERC61041.pdf .

MISO Cinergy Hub Transactions : docket No . IN 12 - 2 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-19 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2014/149FERC61278.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2014/149FERC61278.pdf .

Constellation Energy Commodities Group Inc : docket No . IN 12 - 7 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/138FERC61168.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/138FERC61168.pdf .

ETRACOM LLC and Michael Rosenberg : docket No . IN 16 - 2 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/155FERC61284.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/155FERC61284.pdf .

MISO virtual and FTR trading : docket No . IN 12 - 6 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-10-30 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2014/146FERC61072.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2014/146FERC61072.pdf .

Gila River Power LLC : docket No . IN 12 - 8 - 00 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-10-17 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/EventCalendar/Files/20121119104332-IN12-8-000.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/EventCalendar/Files/20121119104332-IN12-8-000.pdf .

TAYLOR G , LEDGERWOOD S D , BROEHM R , et al . Market power and market manipulation in energy markets: from the California crisis to the present [M]. Reston , USA: Public Utilities Reports Inc , 2015 .

Fifth replacement FERC electric tariff [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. http://www.caiso.com/Documents/ConformedTariff-asof-Jan1-2019.pdf http://www.caiso.com/Documents/ConformedTariff-asof-Jan1-2019.pdf .

Investigation of terms and conditions of public utility market-based rate authorizations : docket No . EL 01 - 118 - 000 and EL 01 - 118 - 001 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/111303/e-3.pdf https://ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/111303/e-3.pdf .

Enron Power Marketing Inc and Enron Energy Services : docket No . EL 03 - 180 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://ferc.gov/industries/electric/indus-act/wec/gaming-initial-decision.pdf https://ferc.gov/industries/electric/indus-act/wec/gaming-initial-decision.pdf .

Guidance note on the application of article 5 of remit on the prohibition of market manipulation wash trades [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://www.acer-remit.eu/portal/document-download?documentId=u518na123yg https://www.acer-remit.eu/portal/document-download?documentId=u518na123yg .

In re make-whole payments and related bidding strategies : docket No . IN 11 - 8 - 000 and IN 13 - 5 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://ferc.gov/EventCalendar/Files/20130730080931-IN11-8-000.pdf https://ferc.gov/EventCalendar/Files/20130730080931-IN11-8-000.pdf .

Houlian Chen Powhatan Energy Fund LLC HEEP Fund , LLC CU Fund : docket No . V 15 - 3 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2015/151FERC61179.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2015/151FERC61179.pdf .

City Power Marketing LLC and K Stephen Tsingas : docket No . IN 15 - 5 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-02 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2015/152FERC61012.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2015/152FERC61012.pdf .

Coaltrain Energy L P , Peter Jones , Shawn Sheehan , Robert Jones , Jeff Miller , Jack Wells , and Adam Hughes : docket No . IN 16 - 4 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/155FERC61204.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/155FERC61204.pdf .

Regional reliability standard PRC- 006 -NPCC- 1 —automatic under frequency load shedding [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-11 ]. https://ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/2013/022113/E-4.pdf https://ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/2013/022113/E-4.pdf .

Berkshire Power Company LLC Power Plant Management Services LLC : docket No . IN 16 - 3 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-10 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/154FERC61259.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/154FERC61259.pdf .

In re Holyoke Gas and Electric Department : docket No . IN 12 - 3 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-10-29 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/137ferc61159.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/137ferc61159.pdf .

Maxim Power Corporation , Maxim Power (USA) Holding Company Inc , Pawtucket Power Holding Co LLC , Pittsfield Generating Company L P , and Kyle Mitton : docket No . IN 15 - 4 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-01 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/CalendarFiles/20150501182246-IN15-4-000A.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/CalendarFiles/20150501182246-IN15-4-000A.pdf .

Competitive Energy Services LLC : docket No . IN 12 - 12 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-09-29 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/144FERC61163.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/2016/144FERC61163.pdf .

Enerwise Global Technologies Inc : docket No . IN 12 - 15 - 000 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-07 ]. https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/143FERC61218.pdf https://ferc.gov/enforcement/civil-penalties/actions/143FERC61218.pdf .

Guidance on the application of regulation No . 1227 / 2011 of the European parliament and the council of 25 October 2011 on wholesale energy market integrity and transparency [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. http://www.acer.europa.eu/official_documents/other%20documents/4th%20edition%20acer%20guidance%20remit.pdf http://www.acer.europa.eu/official_documents/other%20documents/4th%20edition%20acer%20guidance%20remit.pdf .

18 CFR parts 250 and 385 civil monetary penalty inflation adjustments [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-17 ]. https://www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/order-826.pdf https://www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/order-826.pdf .

Statutes of Alberta , 2007 Chapter A- 37 [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-12 ]. https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2015/06/f22/U016.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2015/06/f22/U016.pdf .

Market rules for the Ontario electricity market [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-04 ]. http://www.ieso.ca/-/media/files/ieso/document-library/market-rules-and-manuals-library/market-rules/mr-marketrules.pdf http://www.ieso.ca/-/media/files/ieso/document-library/market-rules-and-manuals-library/market-rules/mr-marketrules.pdf .

陈雨果 , 张轩 , 罗钢 , 等 . 用户报量不报价模式下电力现货市场需求响应机制与方法 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2019 , 43 ( 9 ): 179 - 186 .

CHEN Yuguo , ZHANG Xuan , LUO Gang , et al . Demand response mechanism and approach of electricity spot market in bidding mode without price on user side [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2019 , 43 ( 9 ): 179 - 186 .

刘永奇，邹鹏，燕争上，等 . 山西电力调频市场机制设计与运营实践 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2019 , 43 ( 16 ): 175 - 182 .

LIU Yongqi , ZOU Peng , YAN Zhengshang , et al . Mechanism design and operation practice of Shanxi power frequency regulation market in China [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2019 , 43 ( 16 ): 175 - 182 .

胡朝阳，毕晓亮，王珂，等 . 促进负备用跨省调剂的华东电力调峰辅助服务市场设计 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2019 , 43 ( 5 ): 175 - 182 .

HU Zhaoyang , BI Xiaoliang , WANG Ke , et al . Design of peak regulation auxiliary service market for East China power grid to promote inter-provincial sharing of negative reserve [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2019 , 43 ( 5 ): 175 - 182 .

浙江省电力体制改革综合试点方案 [EB/OL].[ 2019-11-10 ]. http://zjjcmspublic.oss-cn-hangzhou-zwynet-d01-a.internet.cloud.zj.gov.cn/jcms_files/jcms1/web3096/site/attach/-1/201710161455572617.pdf http://zjjcmspublic.oss-cn-hangzhou-zwynet-d01-a.internet.cloud.zj.gov.cn/jcms_files/jcms1/web3096/site/attach/-1/201710161455572617.pdf .

Comprehensive pilot plan for electric power system reform of Zhejiang Province [EB/OL]. [ 2019-11-10 ]. http://zjjcmspublic.oss-cn-hangzhou-zwynet-d01-a.internet.cloud.zj.gov.cn/jcms_files/jcms1/web3096/site/attach/-1/2017101614 55572617.pdf http://zjjcmspublic.oss-cn-hangzhou-zwynet-d01-a.internet.cloud.zj.gov.cn/jcms_files/jcms1/web3096/site/attach/-1/201710161455572617.pdf .

史连军，庞博，刘敦楠，等 . 新电改下北京电力交易中心电力市场综合指数的交易分析 [J]. 电力系统自动化 , 2019 , 43 ( 6 ): 163 - 170 .

SHI Lianjun , PANG Bo , LIU Dunnan , et al . Power market transaction analysis of index of Beijing Electric Power Exchange Center under new electricity reform [J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems , 2019 , 43 ( 6 ): 163 - 170 .

浏览量

下载量

CSCD

文章被引用时，请邮件提醒。

提交

工具集

关联资源

面向社会福利最大化的跨价区中长期净可用传输能力计算模型

面向发电主体的超额收益监测及分析方法

风-光-抽蓄辅助服务市场容量交易随机演化博弈